Some news outlets have shown skewed footage of stabbing incidents, misrepresented facts in articles
At an Israeli bus station, several uniformed officers surround an Arab woman before opening fire on her, dropping her to the ground. Standing over her motionless body, a Border Police officer toting an automatic rifle speaks into a radio while another officer chases away a bystander documenting the scene on his cellphone.
That’s how the Dutch public broadcaster NOS
presented an October 9 incident in the northern city of Afula, in which
Israeli officers shot and arrested Asraa Zidan Tawfik Abed, an Arab
Israeli woman from Nazareth who the police said had tried to stab a
soldier at the city’s main bus station.
NOS used only 13 seconds of the 52-second
cellphone video, dispensing with footage that showed Abed holding the
knife aloft and making stabbing motions while officers shouted at her to
drop the weapon. The full video also showed Abed alive despite being
shot.
Marcel Gelauff, the chief editor at NOS News,
defended his network’s coverage of the incident, telling JTA that it was
not aiming to provide “a clear and detailed picture” of what
transpired, but rather “an impression of a few events.” Gelauff added
that NOS regularly receives complaints of perceived bias from both sides
and noted that the title of the segment, “Violence in Israel is
expanding,” demonstrates that “we are dealing with growing violence from
both sides.”
But critics of European media coverage of
Israel say the choice not to show the full video is emblematic of how
missing or misleading context distorts public perceptions of the recent
upsurge in violence in the region — mostly to Israel’s disadvantage.
“No media in Europe have recognized who’s
attacking whom, to my knowledge,” said Simon Plosker, the Israel-based
managing editor of HonestReporting.com, which monitors international
news coverage of Israel. “Palestinians who are carrying out the attacks
are being portrayed as victims who are presumably being driven to
desperate measures by Israeli policies.” Read more.
No comments:
Post a Comment